Discussion about this post

User's avatar
William Weaver's avatar

"JD Vance (aka Thielbot 3000)…" Thielbot 3000" LMAO!! Gold!

Expand full comment
Myq Kaplan's avatar

dear matt,

thoughtful piece!

i have an answer to this question you ask: "Is the left for or against DEI?"

now, i don't speak for the entire left, but my understanding is that most progressives would say they are for diversity, equity, and inclusion.

AND ALSO, folks on the right have taken the term and used it in a way that adds connotations of favoritism and a lack of merit in hiring, similar to how they once did with the term "affirmative action," when there are empirical studies demonstrating that such measures have helped make progress towards the goals of lessening the effects of a historically racist system in hiring (i read about it in the book "so you want to talk about race" which i remember being great, and very thorough with examples and statistics). neither DEI nor affirmative action has the goal of elevating unqualified folks, but that is how the right has painted it. "ah, an affirmative action hire." or "ah, a DEI hire." so, i think the intent (and the actual results) of such initiatives are what progressives want, and what they DON'T want is the negative associations that folks on the right have applied to the terms with their messaging (something i think you have written about, that they are good at).

does that make sense?

thanks for asking, and sharing as you do!

love

myq

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts